Book Series

A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder

A young-adult mystery series by Holly Jackson following Pippa Fitz-Amobi as a school investigation into a closed murder case leads her into further secrets and danger.

Join discussion

A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder in Captivating Mystery Book Series

Published rank#1Previous #1
Eligible ratings4included in this publication
Category size7ranked entities
Current publication#2220 Nov 2026

Published over time

Rank history

—
Latest 10 publications
#3#3#6#2#1#1#1#1#1#1
P13P14P15P16P17P18P19P20P21P22
Published history data
PublicationDateRank
Publication #1210 Nov 2026#3 of 7
Publication #1311 Nov 2026#3 of 7
Publication #1412 Nov 2026#3 of 7
Publication #1513 Nov 2026#6 of 7
Publication #1614 Nov 2026#2 of 7
Publication #1715 Nov 2026#1 of 7
Publication #1816 Nov 2026#1 of 7
Publication #1917 Nov 2026#1 of 7
Publication #2018 Nov 2026#1 of 7
Publication #2119 Nov 2026#1 of 7
Publication #2220 Nov 2026#1 of 7

Published performance

Ranking highlights

Best recorded rank
#1
First recorded appearance
Publication #12
Recorded appearances
11
Current streak
#1 for 6 publications
Change since first appearance
Up 2 places
Ranking method
ranking-v2

A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder placed #1 of 7 in Captivating Mystery Book Series in AuraRank Publication #22, published 20 Nov 2026, with 4 eligible ratings.

AURARANK ASSESSMENTIndependent AuraRank Assessment, separate from user ratings.

Overview

A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder pairs an accessible, clue-rich investigation with an increasingly personal sense of danger, giving Pip’s methods and choices real narrative weight. Its connected books broaden the mystery beyond the original case, though the evidence for the full series’ consistency and the deductibility of every major revelation is less certain.

Read full assessment

Assessment scope

Assesses Holly Jackson’s book series, focusing on the first two novels and the publisher’s descriptions of the third and prequel; the television adaptation is excluded. Evidence is strongest for the first book’s structure and pacing, and more limited for series-wide clue fairness and consistency.

Assessment at a glance

  • Mystery constructionStrong
  • Clue fairnessStrong
  • Suspense and pacingStrong
  • Characters and investigationStrong
  • Series developmentStrong
Grade key

Very weak: substantial weaknesses · Below expectations: important gaps · Adequate: meets basic expectations · Strong: performs well · Exceptional: outstanding performance against the criterion.

Criteria findings

1. Mystery construction

Strong

Well-designed central questions and coherent resolutions grounded in the story.

The opening book builds a clear question around a supposedly settled disappearance and murder, then uses discrepancies in accounts and evidence to drive a layered resolution. The case is designed to make the original explanation worth questioning, though the available evidence does not establish that every reveal will feel equally convincing to every reader.

Evidence confidence: high

2. Clue fairness

Strong

Clues and revelations support deduction without relying on arbitrary twists.

Pip’s notes, interviews, project logs, and other documentary elements expose information as she gathers it, while red herrings and shifting accounts give readers material to reconsider. The evidence supports purposeful clue placement, but does not establish that all major turns can be reliably deduced in advance.

Evidence confidence: medium

3. Suspense and pacing

Strong

Sustains curiosity and tension while progressing the investigation.

Threats against Pip, a growing suspect pool, and the risk of reopening painful events keep the investigation urgent; the follow-up raises the stakes with a friend’s missing brother and a time-marked trail of evidence. The fast-moving, layered presentation is a strength, although it may leave less room for some readers to pause over the investigation.

Evidence confidence: high

4. Characters and investigation

Strong

Compelling characters whose choices and investigative methods make sense.

Pip’s curiosity and personal unease give her investigation a comprehensible motive, and her use of interviews, timelines, and records makes the sleuthing central to the story. Her choices also carry social and personal consequences; the evidence available here is less conclusive about how consistently every character’s decisions withstand scrutiny across all installments.

Evidence confidence: medium

5. Series development

Strong

Maintains continuity and fresh mysteries across books without excessive repetition.

The subsequent books shift from revisiting a closed murder case to investigating a disappearance and carry forward Pip’s relationships and the fallout from her earlier work. This creates a meaningful progression, but the available evidence does not establish how consistently the later mysteries remain distinct or how fully the main trilogy resolves its continuity.

Evidence confidence: medium

Supporting sources
Assessment basis✓ Evidence reviewed✓ AI-assisted research
Last assessed13 Nov 2026

More about A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder

LISTING PLUSCarefully researched. Errors are possible, and details may change.

Overview

A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder is Holly Jackson’s young-adult mystery series about Pip Fitz-Amobi, a teenager who revisits a closed murder case for a school project. Her investigation challenges the accepted account and uncovers secrets that put her in danger.

The main story follows three novels: A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder, Good Girl, Bad Blood, and As Good as Dead. The books follow publication order, with Pip’s investigations and their consequences developing across the trilogy. The publisher also lists the related novella Kill Joy separately from the three main books.

The series is aimed at teen readers and blends mystery, crime, and thriller elements. A television adaptation has been released; its availability depends on region and service. The books are available in multiple formats, but edition and publisher listings vary by market.

Read full Listing Plus

Highlights

  • Follows Pip Fitz-Amobi as she investigates a closed murder case and questions the accepted account.
  • The main story is a three-book sequence, with later books continuing Pip’s investigations.
  • A separate related novella, Kill Joy, is not counted among the three main books.
  • Teen-focused mystery and thriller fiction involving crime and true-crime podcast elements.
  • An official television adaptation has been released; viewing availability varies by region.

Tags

  • Young adult
  • Mystery
  • Crime fiction
  • Thriller
  • Book series

Quick facts

AuthorHolly Jackson
First published2019
PublisherElectric Monkey (UK); Delacorte Press (US)
Series statusComplete trilogy
Reading orderRead the three main novels in publication order: A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder; Good Girl, Bad Blood; As Good as Dead. Kill Joy is a related novella, not one of the main trilogy.
GenresYoung adult mystery
Crime fiction
Thriller
Original languageEnglish
Reading audienceTeen readers; US publisher lists the first book for ages 14 and up.
AdaptationsTelevision adaptation released by the BBC and Netflix; distribution and availability vary by region.
Supporting sources
Research checks✓ Evidence reviewed✓ AI-assisted research
Last updated13 Nov 2026

Discuss A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder

DISCUSSIONDifferent perspectives can reveal missing context.

Topics

No public topics yet.
Report an issue